6 Hauntingly Wonderful Haunted Hotels in New York 2025

New York, the Empire State, is known for its bustling cities, iconic landmarks, and a rich history. But did you know it also boasts a collection of charming, historic hotels with a twist? Yes, you read that right, haunted hotels!

Now, before you start imagining restless spirits causing chaos, let me assure you, these are not your typical spine-tingling haunts. Instead, these hotels offer a delightful blend of elegant accommodations, cool histories, and, yes, a sprinkle of ghostly encounters that add to their allure.

So, if you're seeking a unique and unforgettable stay in the Empire State, join us as we explore the enchanting world of haunted hotels in New York that are, believe it or not, wonderful places to spend a night...or several!

Brief History

Ah, the Hotel Chelsea in New York City! This place oozes history, culture, and, some say, a touch of the supernatural. Imagine a building that's seen more drama than a Shakespearean play and hosted more artists than a hipster's loft party. Well, that's the Chelsea for you.

Built in 1883, this grand old dame started life as a co-op apartment building. But things took a turn when it converted into a hotel in 1905. From then on, it became a haven for artists, writers, and musicians looking for a slice of bohemian paradise. The Chelsea Hotel is the kind of place where you might bump into the likes of Mark Twain, Thomas Wolfe, or Arthur C. Clarke in the elevator (assuming they're ghostwriting their next masterpiece).

The hotel's claim to fame? The "Chelsea Girls" film by Andy Warhol that was partly shot there in the 1960s. Warhol's Factory crowd practically lived there, making the Chelsea a hub for creative chaos and, let's face it, a fair bit of debauchery.

The Chelsea Hotel is like a time capsule of New York's artistic history. Bob Dylan composed songs here, Jack Kerouac typed away, and countless musicians strummed their guitars in smoky rooms. But it's not all roses and sunshine – it's seen its fair share of tragedies and dark moments too.

Despite renovations and changes over the years, the Chelsea still stands proudly, a living (and maybe a little haunted) testament to the bohemian spirit of NYC. So, if you want to soak up some culture, feel the ghosts of creative genius, or just maybe catch a glimpse of a spectral poet scribbling in the corner, the Chelsea Hotel is the place to be.

Hauntings

Well, grab your ghost-hunting gear and your artistic sensibilities because we're about to delve into the spooky and creative world of the Hotel Chelsea in New York! This place isn't just famous for its artistic residents; it's got a reputation for some ghostly company as well.

First up, we've got the spirit of Welsh poet Dylan Thomas. He was known to frequent the Chelsea, and rumor has it that he loved it so much that he never really left. Some folks claim to have heard him whispering poetry in the halls, perhaps seeking inspiration from the afterlife.

Then there's the tale of Nancy Spungen. She's a bit of a punk rock legend due to her tragic demise, allegedly at the hands of Sid Vicious of the Sex Pistols. Some believe Nancy's restless spirit lingers in the Chelsea, maybe in the room where she met her unfortunate end.

But wait, there's more! The Chelsea Hotel has so many ghostly stories that you could write a whole book about them. Guests and staff have reported strange noises, flickering lights, and unexplained apparitions. Some have even claimed to witness furniture moving on its own, as if the spirits are redecorating.

It's said that the hotel's eerie ambiance isn't just a result of its famous former residents; it's also due to its unique architecture, which includes long, labyrinthine hallways and creaky old floors. All of this adds to the eerie charm that makes you wonder if you're alone in your room at night.

So, if you're up for a thrilling stay and a dash of artistic inspiration, check in and see if you can make a spectral friend or two. Just don't forget to say "hi" to Dylan and Nancy for us!

Why The Chelsea Hotel Is HotMamaTravel Approved

The Chelsea Hotel is one of those legendary New York spots where the walls practically hum with stories. Sure, it’s famous for its bohemian past and rumored hauntings (a HotMamaTravel win right there), but what makes it family-approved today is how it blends that artsy, historic vibe with modern comfort.

Families will love that rooms and suites are spacious by NYC standards, giving you room to breathe after a day of city adventures. Add in an indoor pool (a rare gem in Manhattan hotels), on-site dining that makes mealtime easy, and a location that puts you right in the heart of the action—you’ve got a stay that works for both kids and parents.

And since you’re already in the city, why not explore beyond Chelsea? My guide to the five boroughs of New York City breaks down the best family-friendly finds across Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and Staten Island—because NYC adventures don’t stop at your hotel door.

The Chelsea Hotel is HotMamaTravel approved because it serves up history, hauntings, family comfort, and that unbeatable New York energy all under one roof.

See Photos, Reviews, & More

Brief History

The Algonquin Hotel in New York City, where history, elegance, and a dash of wit come together in one delightful cocktail of a building! This place isn't just a hotel; it's a living, breathing piece of New York's literary and cultural history.

Picture this: It's 1902, and New York's theater and literary scenes are buzzing like a beehive in a flower field. That's when the Algonquin Hotel opened its doors. It quickly became the hub for the city's creative minds, especially during the early 20th century.

The Algonquin Round Table was where the magic happened. Imagine Dorothy Parker, Robert Benchley, and other sharp-tongued writers and wits gathering for lunch, trading quips like they were currency. These were the original influencers, and their daily meetings at the Round Table were like a precursor to today's Twitter feuds.

Speaking of Dorothy Parker, she's one of the Algonquin's most famous residents. Known for her acerbic wit and sharp humor, she penned many of her most famous works within the hotel's walls. Legend has it that her spirit still lingers, ready to critique your cocktail choices or your choice of words.

Over the years, the Algonquin has hosted countless luminaries, from playwrights and actors to politicians and journalists. It's a place where creativity sparks in every corner, and where you can almost feel the echoes of conversations that shaped literary history.

Now, it's not just the brilliant minds that haunt this place; it's also rumored to have a few friendly ghosts. Guests have reported strange occurrences and mysterious happenings, as if the hotel's past inhabitants are still enjoying their literary discussions.

So, if you find yourself in the heart of Manhattan and you're seeking a dose of history with a side of spirited conversation, the Algonquin Hotel is your place to be. It's where the past meets the present, where words come to life, and where you might just have a witty encounter with a resident ghost or two. Cheers to the Algonquin!

Hauntings

Gather 'round, because the Algonquin Hotel in New York City has its fair share of ghostly tales to tell, and they're the kind that'll make you both shiver and smile.

First off, let's talk about the star of the spectral show: the legendary wit herself, Dorothy Parker. She's rumored to be the unofficial queen of this paranormal party. You see, Dorothy was known for her sharp tongue and clever quips during her heyday at the Algonquin. It seems she couldn't resist the urge to continue her witty banter from beyond the grave. Some guests have claimed to hear her disembodied voice whispering words of wisdom, or perhaps just some well-timed sarcasm.

But Dorothy isn't alone in this spirited soirée. The ghost of a mysterious "Man in a Grey Suit" has been spotted roaming the halls. Nobody knows exactly who this dapper apparition might be, but he sure adds a touch of elegance to the hotel's spectral roster.

Now, don't think the Algonquin's ghosts are all about conversation. Some have reported feeling strange cold spots, flickering lights, and unexplained noises. It's as if the spirits are putting on a variety show to keep guests entertained.

But here's the thing about the Algonquin's hauntings: they're not spooky in a scary way. It's more like the ghosts are continuing the tradition of the Algonquin Round Table, where clever minds gathered for witty repartee. You might even say that these spirits are here for a literary critique or two.

So, if you're checking into the Algonquin Hotel, don't be surprised if you find yourself in a conversation with the supernatural. And remember, if you hear a disembodied voice cracking a clever joke or critiquing your fashion choices, it's probably just Dorothy Parker, keeping the party alive in the afterlife. Cheers to spirited soirées at the Algonquin!

Why The Algonquin Hotel Is HotMamaTravel Approved

The Algonquin Hotel is dripping with old New York charm, and that’s exactly why it’s HotMamaTravel approved. This legendary Midtown spot has been welcoming guests for over a century, mixing historic character with family-friendly comfort. Its biggest claim to fame? The famous Round Table, where writers and actors once gathered (and where parents can soak up some cultural cred).

Families will love the central location. You’re walking distance to Times Square, Broadway shows, and Bryant Park, which means no long subway hauls with tired kiddos. The hotel also offers spacious suites perfect for families, on-site dining for easy meals, and even a resident lobby cat, Hamlet, who’s basically a built-in kid distraction.

The Algonquin is HotMamaTravel approved because it proves you don’t have to trade history and sophistication for family convenience. You get both, with a dash of literary legacy.

See Photos, Reviews, & More

Brief History

The story begins in 1883 when hotelier Myron O. Brown opened the doors of the first Sagamore, a grand hotel that quickly became a haven for well-heeled travelers seeking respite in the pristine wilderness. The name "Sagamore" itself is a nod to the Native American term for a tribal chief, hinting at the resort's majestic status.

The Sagamore has seen its fair share of history. It weathered a devastating fire in 1893 but emerged stronger, rebuilt in the charming Victorian style that still captivates guests today. During World War II, the resort transformed into a training ground for the U.S. Navy, hosting thousands of sailors.

Over the decades, it's welcomed famous faces, from presidents like Franklin D. Roosevelt to Hollywood celebrities seeking a slice of lakeside paradise. The Sagamore Resort has maintained its reputation as a luxurious retreat. It's the kind of place where you can sip a cocktail on the veranda, soak in Lake George's beauty, and imagine the whispers of history echoing through the halls.

Hauntings

Well, folks, if you ever find yourself wandering the halls of the Sagamore Resort on Lake George in New York, keep an eye out for more than just stunning lake views and cozy fireplaces. You might just stumble upon a ghostly guest or two!

First up, we have "The Smoker," a mysterious spirit who's quite the enigma. This spectral character apparently enjoys puffing on an invisible cigar in the resort's elegant hallways. Now, I've heard of secondhand smoke, but this is taking it to a whole new level!

But The Smoker isn't the resort's only phantom. Some guests have reported encountering shadowy figures and hearing eerie sounds when the moonlight dances on the lake's surface. It's like a supernatural symphony by the water's edge.

Now, let's be clear, the hauntings at the Sagamore Resort aren't of the hair-raising, terrifying variety. It's more like the spirits are just enjoying the resort's luxurious amenities in the afterlife. Who can blame them, right? Imagine being a ghost with eternal access to those lake views!

So, if you decide to check into the Sagamore, don't be surprised if you hear a faint puffing sound in the hallway or glimpse a figure out of the corner of your eye. It's all part of the resort's quirky charm, where the living and the not-so-living can share a lakeside vacation. Just remember to say a polite "hello" to The Smoker if you see him; ghostly manners are important, after all!

Why The Sagamore Is HotMamaTravel Approved

The Sagamore Hotel isn’t just another pretty lakeside stay; it’s the full HotMamaTravel package. Perched on Lake George, this historic gem has all the makings of a dreamy family getaway: gorgeous views, activities for the kids, a touch of luxury for the parents, and, of course, a dash of ghostly lore to keep things interesting. Yep, The Sagamore is famously haunted, which earns it major bonus points in my book. Because why settle for ordinary when you can have history, haunts, and a killer setting all in one?

And if your family vibe leans more campfire than chandelier, don’t worry—Upstate New York also delivers with some epic family-friendly glamping spots that let you swap ghost stories under the stars. Or maybe you’re the type who likes to toast your haunted adventures—if so, check out my guide to the best family-friendly breweries in Seneca, where parents can sip local craft beer while the kids play.

The Sagamore Hotel is a HotMamaTravel-approved destination because it’s the rare spot that offers everything: relaxation, adventure, and just enough spook factor to make your trip unforgettable.

See Photos, Reviews, & More

Brief History

Nestled in the picturesque Shawangunk Mountains of upstate New York, the Mohonk Mountain House is a historic resort that's been offering guests a taste of natural beauty and Victorian elegance since its inception in 1869.

The story begins with twin brothers Albert and Alfred Smiley, who had a vision of creating a peaceful retreat amidst the rugged wilderness. They acquired a small inn and gradually expanded it into the grand mountain resort it is today. The Mohonk Mountain House was designed in a stunning Victorian style, with turrets, balconies, and verandas that provide breathtaking views of the surrounding landscape.

From its early days, the resort has been a sanctuary for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts. Guests could hike, swim, boat, and take in the fresh mountain air. The resort's pristine lake, Lake Mohonk, offered a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of city life.

Throughout its history, the Mohonk Mountain House has hosted notable figures, including U.S. Presidents, artists, and writers seeking inspiration from the serene surroundings. It's also known for its commitment to environmental conservation and sustainability, a tradition that began in the late 19th century and continues today.

As for its alleged hauntings, the Mohonk Mountain House has its share of ghostly tales. One of the most famous involves a little girl who tragically drowned in the lake. Some guests claim to have seen her ghostly figure or heard her laughter echoing by the water.

Hauntings

Hold onto your hiking boots because we're about to dive into the delightfully eerie world of the Mohonk Mountain House hauntings!

First up, the ghostly girl of Lake Mohonk. Legend has it that a young girl tragically drowned in the lake many moons ago. But her spirit seems to have decided that her vacation wasn't quite over, as guests have reported seeing her apparition near the water's edge. Some even say they've heard her playful laughter dancing on the wind.

Now, if you're thinking about a relaxing soak in the hotel's charming Victorian-era spa, you might just have a bath buddy from the other side. Guests have reported mysterious appearances of a ghostly figure in the spa area, adding an extra layer of relaxation or perhaps an unexpected conversation starter to your spa day.

But it's not all watery apparitions and spa specters. The Mohonk Mountain House has its fair share of creaks, groans, and inexplicable sounds that could give even the bravest guests a case of the goosebumps. It's as if the old walls have stories to tell, and they're not shy about sharing them.

Now, these ghosts aren't your typical spooky spirits. They seem more like they're just adding a bit of supernatural flair to your mountain getaway. Think of them as the original guests who never quite checked out, adding an extra layer of charm to the already enchanting Mohonk Mountain House.

If you're looking for more outdoor experiences, consider our favorite glamping sites in Upstate New York.

Why The Mohonk Mountain House Is HotMamaTravel Approved

The Mohonk Mountain House is like stepping into a storybook castle, only this one sits on the shores of a sparkling lake in the Hudson Valley and is packed with things kids (and parents) will actually love. This historic Victorian resort delivers big on family fun: think year-round activities like swimming, hiking, ice skating, paddleboarding, and even camp-style kids’ programs so mom and dad can sneak off to the spa or enjoy a cocktail by the fire.

Rooms and suites are roomy enough for the whole crew, and the all-inclusive setup means meals are handled (a huge win for families). The lakefront location and surrounding mountains give kids endless space to run, explore, and burn off energy while parents soak in the views and that classic Mohonk charm.

Mohonk Mountain House is HotMamaTravel approved because it nails the trifecta: jaw-dropping setting, nonstop family activities, and a historic vibe that makes your stay feel like something special. This isn’t just a hotel; it’s a full-on family memory-maker.

See Photos, Reviews, & More

Brief History

The Otesaga Resort Hotel, located in Cooperstown, New York, is a historic and elegant lakeside retreat with a rich history dating back to 1909.

The story begins with the Clark family, who envisioned creating a luxurious resort on the shores of Otsego Lake. They commissioned architect Percy Griffin to design a grand hotel that would complement the area's natural beauty. The result was the Otesaga Resort, a stunning example of Colonial Revival architecture.

From its early days, the Otesaga has been a favorite destination for travelers seeking relaxation and recreation. Its picturesque location near the Baseball Hall of Fame and the Farmers' Museum has made it a popular choice for visitors exploring the cultural and natural attractions of Cooperstown.

Over the years, the Otesaga has hosted numerous notable guests, including celebrities, politicians, and even several U.S. presidents. Its reputation for luxury and hospitality has made it a beloved destination for weddings, conferences, and leisure getaways.

The resort offers a wide range of amenities, including a golf course, a spa, and fine dining options. Its charming lakeside setting and elegant ambiance make it a sought-after destination for those looking to experience the beauty and history of upstate New York.

Hauntings

This charming lakeside retreat, located in Cooperstown, is known not only for its stunning views of Otsego Lake and its rich history but also for a few ghostly guests who seem to have checked in... and never left.

First up, we have the tale of "The Lady in White." Rumor has it that a ghostly woman, clad in a flowing white dress, roams the hallways of the Otesaga. Perhaps she's still searching for her lost love or maybe just enjoying the luxurious accommodations from the great beyond.

Then there's the story of the mysterious "Crying Lady." Some guests have reported hearing sobs echoing through the hallways in the dead of night. Is it the lament of a bygone era or simply the sound of someone who couldn't resist the temptation of the resort's exquisite spa treatments?

But don't let these tales scare you off. The Otesaga's ghostly residents are said to be more playful than spooky. There have been reports of lights flickering, objects moving on their own, and even the sensation of someone gently tucking you in at night. It's as if the spirits want to ensure your stay is nothing short of magical.

So, if you decide to tee off at the Leatherstocking Golf Course or take a leisurely stroll along the lake at the Otesaga Resort, keep an eye out for these friendly apparitions. They're just adding an extra layer of charm to this historic gem in Cooperstown, making your stay a memorable blend of luxury, natural beauty, and the possibility of a playful spectral encounter.

Why The Otesaga Resort Is HotMamaTravel Approved

The Otesaga Resort Hotel is one of those rare stays that makes the whole family happy. Set right on the shores of Lake Otsego, this grand historic resort has that classic “summer retreat” feel—only with all the modern comforts families need. Kids will love the outdoor pool, lake activities like canoeing and kayaking, and plenty of wide-open lawns to run wild. Parents will appreciate the elegant touches, from the lakeside dining to the golf course and spa.

Rooms and suites are spacious enough for families, and the resort’s location is unbeatable. You’re steps from the National Baseball Hall of Fame (hello, family field trip) and charming downtown Cooperstown. It’s the kind of place where you can mix history, sports, and relaxation all in one trip.

The Otesaga is HotMamaTravel approved because it blends lakefront fun, family-friendly amenities, and old-world charm into one unforgettable getaway. Whether you’re chasing baseball legends or lakeside sunsets, this resort checks all the boxes.

See Photos, Reviews, & More

Brief History

Alright, folks, buckle up for a journey back in time to the roaring twenties when Hotel Utica in New York was the place to see and be seen. This hotel is like a living, breathing time capsule of Utica's rich history and a dash of whimsy.

In 1912 Utica's social scene is bustling. The Hotel Utica arose as a symbol of opulence, boasting stunning Beaux-Arts architecture that's as grand as the Gatsby era itself. If those walls could talk, they'd whisper tales of jazz-filled nights and flapper dresses that dazzled under the ballroom's shimmering chandeliers.

The hotel quickly became the go-to spot for visitors and locals alike, hosting everyone from politicians to celebrities. It was a hub of activity, with lavish parties and extravagant soirees that would make Jay Gatsby green with envy.

Hauntings

Let's talk about "The Lady in White." She's the star of the show, and she's known to be quite the fashionista from beyond the grave. Dressed in a swanky 1920s white gown, she's like a silent movie star who never left the set. Some guests claim to have seen her ghostly figure gliding along the 10th floor, adding a touch of old-school glamour to the atmosphere.

But she's not the only spectral guest in this haunted hotel. Some visitors have reported strange occurrences, like objects mysteriously moving on their own or lights flickering in a peculiar pattern. It's as if the spirits are having their own paranormal party in the hallways.

Now, here's where it gets even more intriguing. There's the tale of "The Gentleman Ghost." This dapper specter has been spotted in a classic suit and tie, strolling through the hotel like he's about to head to a fancy jazz club. Who says ghosts can't have a sense of style, right?

But fear not, these apparitions are more mischievous than menacing. It's like they're enjoying a never-ending Roaring Twenties party, complete with flapper dresses, dapper gents, and a few supernatural surprises.

So, if you're planning a stay at Hotel Utica, don't be surprised if you encounter a friendly ghostly guest or two. They're just adding an extra layer of excitement to your stay, as if the hotel itself is saying, "Welcome to the party, old sport!"

Why Hotel Utica Is HotMamaTravel Approved

Hotel Utica proves you don’t have to spend a fortune to give your family a memorable New York stay. This historic gem blends vintage charm with modern comfort, all at a price tag that’s refreshingly affordable compared to big-city hotels. Families will appreciate the spacious rooms and suites, free breakfast (because kids are always hungry), and the convenient location for exploring Central New York’s attractions.

While it doesn’t have all the frills of a luxury resort, what it does offer is value, and that means more money left over for family adventures. Plus, the hotel’s storied history and elegant architecture give it a character you won’t find in a standard chain.

Hotel Utica is HotMamaTravel approved because it’s budget-friendly, family-comfortable, and full of charm. It is a perfect home base for families who want New York history without the New York price tag.

See Photos, Reviews, & More

As our journey through the haunted hotels of New York wraps up, one thing’s for sure: these places aren’t just about chasing shadows. They’re about stepping back in time, brushing shoulders with history, and soaking up the kind of stories you just can’t get from a regular hotel stay. For more family-friendly adventures across the city, check out our New York Family Travel guide.

If your family’s ready to keep the spooky fun going, there are plenty more adventures waiting. Check out the best towns to celebrate the Halloween season if you’re planning a fall getaway, or dive into our list of favorite haunted places to visit with kids for ghostly fun the whole crew can handle. Craving more overnight chills? Don’t miss our picks for haunted hotels in other destinations to fuel your next ghost-hunting road trip.

So, if you’re ready for a one-of-a-kind adventure that combines luxurious stays with a dash of mystery, don’t shy away from the spirits. Instead, embrace the enchantment of New York’s haunted hotels, where history, elegance, and just the right amount of eeriness come together to create an unforgettable family travel story. Happy ghost-hunting and happy travels!

If Christmas is more your jam, then check out our favorite New York Christmas Hotels that go all out for the holidays!